If you were at Madison Square Garden for the second show in Radiohead’s two-night NYC run, you were in for a treat. Other than Radiohead playing a massive 24-song show, they came out for not one but two encores and capped the night off with their fan-favorite “Creep.” Thom Yorke has voiced his hatred for the song multiple times and it was a most-unexpected bust-out. According to setlist.fm, this is the first time they performed the song since 2004!

I love how the crowd understands the significance of the performance and hushes for the last part of the song. Goosebumps!

Thanks to LazyLightning, you can watch the encore in glorious 4K.

Check out his footage of Iron Lung below:

If you’re hunting for more footage from the show, checkout YouTube user Tom Florczak’s channel. His position on the floor gives a much more intimate perspective of the show. Check out his footage of “Karma Police.”